Credit builder loan vs. secured card
Both build a payment history. A credit-builder loan has you repay a small loan, usually held in savings until the last payment. A secured card works like a regular credit card with a limit set by your refundable deposit. This calculator puts both on the same footing: what each costs over the months you spend building credit, and how much cash each needs.
| Credit-builder loan | Secured card | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash needed up front | — | — |
| Paid each month | — | — |
| Interest | — | — |
| Fees | — | — |
| Interest your money could have earned instead | — | — |
| You get back at the end | — | — |
| True cost | — | — |
True cost = interest + fees + interest the money could have earned in savings − dividends. The card’s purchases aren’t a cost: you’d buy those things anyway and pay them off. Estimate only. Nothing you enter is saved.
Defaults: APR 5% is the median lowest APR of the 9 savings-held credit-builder loans we track; 18.49% is the median of the lowest APR each secured card publishes; 36 of 45 secured cards charge no annual fee; the savings rate is today’s best no-strings rate open nationwide (4.41% at Mitten Savings).
What each adds to your credit report
A credit-builder loan is an installment account: a fixed payment each month until it’s paid off. A secured card is a revolving account: you use it, pay the statement, and the balance compared with your limit (credit utilization) counts too. Either one helps only if it reports to Equifax, Experian and TransUnion and every payment is on time.
Which to choose
- You can pay a card in full each month: a no-fee secured card usually costs the least, and many issuers review you for an upgrade to an unsecured card.
- You can’t spare a deposit up front: a credit-builder loan spreads the cost into monthly payments and leaves you a small savings balance at the end.
- You tend to carry a card balance: the card’s APR can cost more than a builder loan; a loan has no balance to run up.
- Your file has only cards, or only loans: adding the other type can help your credit mix.
Questions
Which is cheaper, a credit-builder loan or a secured card?
A secured card is usually cheaper if you pay the balance in full every month: 36 of the 45 secured cards we track charge no annual fee, and the deposit comes back. A credit-builder loan always costs its interest and any fees; at the median lowest APR of 5% on the savings-held loans we track, a $1,000 12-month loan costs about $27 in interest. A secured card gets expensive only if you carry a balance at its APR.
Do I get my money back?
With a secured card, the deposit is returned when you close the account in good standing or the issuer upgrades you to an unsecured card. With a savings-held credit-builder loan, the loan amount is released when the last payment is made; the interest and fees are the cost.
Which helps my credit score more?
Both add on-time payments if the lender or issuer reports to all three bureaus. A credit-builder loan adds an installment account; a secured card adds a revolving account, where keeping the balance low compared with the limit also matters. Having both types can help, as long as every payment is on time.
Can I have both?
Yes. Some people open a secured card for everyday use and a small credit-builder loan at the same time. Start with one if money is tight: a missed payment on either hurts more than the second account helps.
Related: credit-builder loans ranked · secured credit cards ranked · credit-builder loan calculator · share-secured loans · credit roadmap